What To Do With Old Beanie Babies – 10 Ideas

You are wondering just what to do about your Beanie Babies collection? We hear you. So you have finally decided to do something about your vast Beanie Babies repertoire, and so far, all you know is that you need to either get rid of them or give them another use, but you are not entirely sure how to proceed. This is exactly why we’ll be sharing with you what to do with old Beanie Babies.

So the day has finally arrived, you have finally grown out of the Beanie Babies stage; however, you have been left with a bunch of Beanie Babies laying somewhere in your basement. If you can’t take to see all those boxes piled up against each other, then you are probably wondering what to do with old Beanie Babies.

To your surprise or not, there are a few things you can do to solve your predicament, with the most prominent being to donate them to another kid who will cherish them as you once did. Keep reading and find out what else you can do about what to do with old Beanie Babies.

What To Do With Old Beanie Babies – 10 Ideas FAQs

What are the nine original Beanie Babies?

The “Original Nine” Beanie Babies were: Legs the Frog, Squealer the Pig, Brownie the Bear (later renamed Cubbie the Bear), Flash the Dolphin, Splash the Whale, Patti the Platypus, Chocolate the Moose, Spot the Dog, and Pinchers the Lobster.

What is a retired Beanie Baby?

The retirement of a Beanie Baby or a product from any line of Ty Inc., the manufacturer of Beanie Babies and other lines of collectibles, is its withdrawal from production. When a Beanie Baby is retired, Ty is no longer produced, though if Ty has some remaining in its stock, these may be shipped to retailers.

Are collectible Beanie Babies a thing?

An industry surfaced with collector magazines devoted to the toys, plastic tag holders (don’t want to crease those cardboard tags), and websites devoted to online newsletters and marketplaces.

Can I sell my old Beanie Babies?

In addition to this, eBay is another common place to list your Beanie Babies for sale. Not only can you sell them out at a “flat rate,” but you can also auction them off, which may earn you even more cash in the long run.

Why are Beanie Babies worth so much?

Beanie Babies were a massive hit in the 1990s, but they quickly faded into relative obscurity. As a rule, the more unique the Beanie Baby, the more valuable it is, which means that certain versions with slight variations in styling or even errors in production often command the highest prices.

How to know how much is my Beanie Babies worth?

A good way to see if a particular Beanie has value now is to check completed listings on eBay. Look for the sold prices, not just starting price, to see if you do have one of those rare beauties. You probably already know it if you do, but it doesn’t hurt to check and make sure.

How much are Beanie Babies worth now?

Aside from a few dozen exceptions, most of the Beanie Babies produced after the first surge of popularity can be purchased for little money today. They are often found at flea markets for $1.00 to $3.00 new.

Should I get rid of my Beanie Babies?

You might consider donating your Beanie Babies if you have a small collection. If you are drowning in Beanie Babies, you can hire a junk removal service to remove them from their home. In conclusion, Check to see if they’re valuable, but if they’re not, they won’t be any more useful in the future.

What is the best way to get rid of Beanie Babies?

Overall, PlushCollector is a safe and secure way for you to get rid of your plush toys at a pretty fair price. You might get a lower price than if you sold your Beanie Babies on an independent marketplace to a collector, but PlushCollector is one of the simplest options for sellers.

Where can I donate my Beanie Babies?

Send Them Packing. Charities such as the Salvation Army and Goodwill likely will sell the Beanie Babies and use the money for other charitable causes.

Do hospitals take Beanie Babies?

Absolutely. However, it is best to check with your local hospital, and then you can send them. Many organizations will put them in ALL of the care packages we ship to deployed Troops.

What To Do With Old Beanie Babies – 10 Ideas

#1 Donate them to your local library

This is where the majority of mine went! Did you know that they use these as prizes for their Summer Reading programs?! I loved this idea. I love the fact that children were doing something educational and receiving my beanie babies as a reward. Contact your local police station or fire station; some may accept them and give them to children in crisis.

#2 Game Time

  • Play with stop motion: Creating stop motion videos can be fun. Why not do some with Beanie Babies? You could also create a Youtube video, such as The Beanie Babies Hunger Games.
  • Noah’s Ark: Did you go overboard and buy duplicate Beanies? Kids love the story of Noah’s Ark, and if you have two of each, why not create an ark out of a cardboard box and have a new way to play with them?
  • The treasure chest at grandma’s house: Beanie Babies are perfect for the treasure chest for grandma’s house. Children will have lots of fun with it and love picking out a special goody.

#3 Contact Operation Christmas Child

These are great to fit in a shoebox and do not take up much space. Children would love to receive a special animal in their box.

#4 Donate to any Children’s Shelter

A local mom is collecting items to create Easter baskets for a shelter. I donated many Easter beanie babies to be included in the baskets.

#5 Contact a preschool teacher or music teacher

A preschool teacher can use them with classroom kids and have different stations throughout the classroom, such as a station where you adopted your pet and received a certificate, a veterinarian station, a station to get a leash/collar, etc.
Dioramas can also be constructed using Beanie Babies for use in ​the classroom and school projects.

#6 Holiday Favors

  • In addition to the usual candy handouts at Halloween, consider giving Beanies, especially the smaller McDonald’s Teenie Beanies.
  • A basket of Beanie Babies under the tree can be extra favors for the kids that show up at your house during the holidays.

#7 Beanie Baby Chair

If you are the crafty type and enjoy using a glue gun, you can find a video and tutorial on creating a stuffed animal chair. At first glance, it looks like a chair with lots of toys thrown on it, but it’s not. It’s around a fabric chair, with dozens of Beanie Babies glued to it.

#8 FrankenBeanies

Imagine the fun of taking apart a Beanie and redoing it into your cryptozoological creature. Put wings on a puppy or giraffe legs on an elephant, for example. And these could be perfect Halloween decorations the next time the holiday rolls around.

#9 A Tree or Wreath

This would be great on a toy-themed or just all Beanie Baby-themed Christmas tree. Use large safety pins in the back of the neck of each bear, and put an ornament hook through the pin for some of the bears. Some might be able to lay on or be tucked into the branches.

#10 Sell your Beanie Babies

If you are the proud owner of any of the “original nine” or the first-ever Beanie Babies produced in small batches in late 1993, you may be interested in selling your Beanie Babies. One of these Beanie Babies will almost always get the attention of toy collectors if it’s in good condition.
Many of the most valuable Beanie Babies today have errors, either on the tags or on the doll itself. The rarity of these errors can make an otherwise worthless toy extremely valuable to collectors.

Additional Tips on What To Do With Old Beanie Babies

  • Learn Beanie Baby terminology; experts refer to this as the hangtag, the swing tag, or just the ear tag. The looped fabric tag stitched to the Beanie Baby’s bottom end is the tush tag, and it can also contain errors that may increase your doll’s value.
  • If you find a misprint on a Beanie Baby tag or some other manufacturing mistake, do some research before getting your hopes up. Some Valentino bears had up to four manufacturing errors, including brown noses instead of black ones and tag typos, which place them among the most sought-after Beanie Babies today.
  • You may have a rare type of Beanie Baby from the early 1990s with a mint-condition ear tag, but if it smells like your basement, you’ll have a hard time selling it. Mold, mildew, and cigarette smoke can all taint your Beanie Babies with hard-to-remove scents.
  • If you’re a buyer, the importance of odor is a good reason to avoid purchasing vintage Beanie Babies online that you can’t see or touch first.

Great ideas, right? Most people also wonder what to do with old Disney VHS tapes.


Photo of author
Stephanie is a mom of two who has been running mommymixing.com since 2020, she provides parents with practical tips, advice and resources to help in their everyday parenting journey.
Photo of author
Stephanie is a mom of two who has been running mommymixing.com since 2020, she provides parents with practical tips, advice and resources to help in their everyday parenting journey.

Share to...